The truth is that the person buried at the witch’s grave is Abel G. Parkhill who was born September 1858 and died on the 14th of February (Valentine’s Day no less) in 1930. He was married to , who he had two children with, Emma 1891 and Nancy 1895. Jennie’s marriage to Abe was her second marriage after her first husband, William Eldridge had passed. Jennie is buried with her son from her first marriage, Jesse who died in 1940. Jennie died in 1924. Since Jennie died prior to Abe, the story of a lonely witch digging up her husband is impossible, unless her ghost was doing the digging.
The Hillside Cemetery began in 1882 in conjunction with the Indian Mission. The land was donated by George Washington Lloyd for the internment of the dead. The first recorded grave was occupied by Jesseen N. Lloyd, daughter of C. W. and lvi A. I Lloyd, in1882. The cemetery is located about 5 miles out of Skiatook. Turn north onto highway 11 (Peoria Avenue) and turn right onto 184th street north which is marked with a Historical Marker sign. Turn East onto the road and follow 184th street until you reach Hillside Cemetery on the right side of the road on the hill.